SLLA618 October   2023 ATL431 , ATL431LI , TL431 , TL431LI , TLVH432

 

  1.   1
  2.   Abstract
  3.   Trademarks
  4. 1Introduction
  5. 2Designing for SSR With a Shunt Reference
    1. 2.1 Setting the Output Voltage
    2. 2.2 Biasing a Shunt Reference
    3. 2.3 Designing for Transient Response
  6. 3Power Considerations
  7. 4Methodology
    1. 4.1 Shunt Reference Implementation
    2. 4.2 Accuracy Comparison
    3. 4.3 Power Consumption Comparison
    4. 4.4 Transient Response Comparison
  8. 5Results
  9. 6Summary
  10. 7References

Shunt Reference Implementation

The UCC28780EVM-021 EVM that was used to perform this experiment originally had an ATL431 shunt reference with a biasing resistance of 34 kΩ. Once test probes were installed, the average cathode voltage, VKA, under a 40 W load was measured to be 16.9 V. When a new shunt reference was soldered onto the board for testing, a new bias current had to be established. Equation 3 was used to calculate the new required biasing resistance, Rbias, where 16.9 V was assumed as the cathode voltage VKA for simplicity. IKA(min) was pulled from the new devices data sheet, and Vout was found using Equation 1. The cathode voltage, VKA, changes according to the programmed output voltage due to the required feedback current to set that output voltage. The TLVH432 has a lower internal reference of 1.24V, meaning that the programmed output voltage is much lower, so R2 was decreased to 10 kΩ to change the programmed output voltage to 19.855 V. The TLVH432's cathode voltage, VKA, was measured at 18.27 V under a 40 W load, which was then used in Equation 3 to calculate the bias resistance, Rbias. The biasing resistance and biasing current provided for each shunt reference for a 40 W load are shown in Table 4-1.

Table 4-1 Shunt Reference Biasing Data
ComponentRbiasIbias (40 W load)IKA(min)Vout (expected)
TL4311.5 kΩ0.99 mA1 mA18.59 V
TLVH43214 kΩ105.9 µA100 µA9.10 V
ATL43134 kΩ44 µA35 µA18.33 V
TL431LI1.5 kΩ0.99 mA1 mA18.32 V
ATL431LI19.1 kΩ77.96 µA80 µA

8.35 V

The following scope images show the steady state performance of each shunt reference under the three-load conditions.

GUID-561A272F-B24C-437E-94D8-290416C7EEE2-low.pngFigure 4-3 TL431 No-Load
GUID-54334282-089B-4C8B-AE0E-2B9112960623-low.pngFigure 4-5 TL431 40 W Load
GUID-CDC1C033-4056-4CF7-B7CB-64990CD86BC8-low.pngFigure 4-7 TLVH432 20 W Load
GUID-26E313C6-A2AA-4F5C-A35A-22F0EAA5EE00-low.pngFigure 4-9 ATL431 No-Load
GUID-5866465B-02FE-4004-8119-A2BE5639B53C-low.pngFigure 4-11 ATL431 40 W Load
GUID-C2202D80-58F3-4FB0-812F-26A0BD3E7E01-low.pngFigure 4-13 TL431LI 20 W Load
GUID-C1E743D8-7BBF-4AA3-A3E0-635BED3E26C2-low.pngFigure 4-15 ATL431LI No-Load
GUID-615E4C93-3A3C-4F00-A176-B4509D379816-low.pngFigure 4-17 ATL431LI 40 W Load
GUID-52573099-BDB9-4C8D-A185-052EC5869257-low.pngFigure 4-4 TL431 20 W Load
GUID-2709BBA6-F981-4AAE-8A98-0B6ED6975DEE-low.pngFigure 4-6 TLVH432 No-Load
GUID-9AF23539-E73C-4096-9A83-7A06318CEF0D-low.pngFigure 4-8 TLVH432 40 W Load
GUID-243BFDE1-1277-42AC-8246-80F97A5E46F7-low.pngFigure 4-10 ATL431 20 W Load
GUID-FD2A6067-209F-4515-A623-EF3EC5BD5C4D-low.pngFigure 4-12 TL431LI No-Load
GUID-CBE85C53-E4FE-411E-A2DC-9654124D30D6-low.pngFigure 4-14 TL431LI 20 W Load
GUID-F648F340-A91C-40F7-8F59-BE12D87643BB-low.pngFigure 4-16 ATL431LI 20 W Load

Vout​​ was measured as the expected programmed value for each of the plots shownand V1 was measured as a slightly lower value than Vout. VAnode and VKA change under different load conditions to modify the secondary side feedback current, IFB(secondary) , through the optocoupler diode. This change in VKA also decreases the biasing current, Ibias, being provided to the shunt reference under larger loads, which is why Ibias was established as IKA(min) at the full-load condition.