SPRAD98A May   2023  – November 2026 TMS320F280033 , TMS320F280034 , TMS320F280034-Q1 , TMS320F280036-Q1 , TMS320F280036C-Q1 , TMS320F280037 , TMS320F280037-Q1 , TMS320F280037C , TMS320F280037C-Q1 , TMS320F280038-Q1 , TMS320F280038C-Q1 , TMS320F280039 , TMS320F280039-Q1 , TMS320F280039C , TMS320F280039C-Q1

 

  1.   1
  2.   Abstract
  3.   Trademarks
  4. 1Introduction
  5. 2Understanding CAT2, PLd Safety Requirements
    1. 2.1 Safety Requirements per the ISO 3691-4 Standard
    2. 2.2 System Architecture Selection
    3. 2.3 Device Selection Based on Process Safety Time
  6. 3Implementing Mobile Robot Motor Drive Safety Requirements
  7. 4Conclusion

Safety Requirements per the ISO 3691-4 Standard

The ISO 3691-4 standard defines the safety requirements and verifications for driverless industrial trucks, including industrial mobile robots (IMRs), such as autonomous mobile robots (AMRs). The standard describes the safety requirements of the overall machine; however, the designer is responsible for determining where the safety functions are placed within the industrial truck modules, as seen in Figure 2-1.

TMS320F280039C Simplified Mobile Robot Block
                    Diagram Figure 2-1 Simplified Mobile Robot Block Diagram

The ISO 3691-4 safety standard describes the safety considerations that must be implemented to meet necessary risk reductions when a hazardous situation exists. For each of the described risk situations, the ISO 3691-4 standard assigns a minimum required performance level (PL) according to the ISO 13849-1 standard. The PL is a value commonly used to achieve the required risk reduction for each safety function and is defined in the machinery standard of ISO 13849-1 (Section one).

Similar to the PL, several standards use the safety integrity level (SIL) to measure the system safety performance. The parameters of the SILs are defined in the IEC 61508 standard. The relationship between the PL and SIL is found in Table 2-1.

Table 2-1 The Relationship Between the IEC 61508 Standard SIL and the ISO 13849 Standard PL
Hardware Fault Tolerance (HFT) Category
IEC 61508 ISO 13849
0 1 2 0 1 2 SFF DC(1) 1 2 3 4
- SIL 1 SIL 2 SIL 1 SIL 2 SIL 3 < 60% None
SIL 1 SIL 2 SIL 3 SIL 2 SIL 3 SIL 4 60% to < 90% Low c c d
SIL 2 SIL 3 SIL 4 SIL 3 SIL 4 SIL 4 90% to < 99% Medium d e
SIL 4 SIL 4 SIL 4 SIL 4 SIL 4 ≤ 99% High e
Type B Type A
Diagnostic coverage (DC).

The SIL and PL both define the safety levels of performance according to the standards used for evaluation (IEC61508 or ISO13849). These levels quantify diagnostic coverage by using different parameters. The SIL uses the safety failure fraction (SFF) as the parameter to quantify the ratio between the safe faults of the system and the total faults of the system. Similarly, the PL refers to the DC parameter as a measure of the effectiveness of the diagnostics implemented in the system. However, DC is the ratio of detected dangerous faults versus all dangerous faults. The SIL and PL are related through two main parameters which are inversely proportional: MTTFd (mean time to dangerous failure)—used in the ISO standards—and PFH (probability of dangerous failure per hour)—used in IEC standards for high demand systems. By using this relationship, using both levels (PL and SIL) is possible when assessing a system for safety.

Table 2-2 PL and SIL Relationship Through PFH and MTTFd Parameters
PL (ISO 13849) PFH Target Values
[PFH = 1/MTTFd]
SIL (IEC 61508, IEC 62061)
a ≥ 10-5 to < 10-4 No correspondence
b ≥ 3 x 10-6 to <10-5 1
c ≥ 10-6 to < 3 x 10-6 1
d ≥ 10-7 to < 10-6 2
e ≥ 10-8 to < 10-7 3

Although the PL or SIL applies to the complete safety function typically formed by sensors, data processing, and actuators, each one of these function subsystems must meet a minimum PL or SIL. For each subsystem, a different standard exists to describe how the safety level is met. As an example, for motor drive and actuator implementations, the specific subsystem standard (IEC 61800-5-2) is used to specify the safety requirements. The IEC 61800-5-2 standard defines the requirements for the design and development of variable speed drives by describing the designated safety subfunctions, for example as safe torque off (STO), safe limited speed (SLS), safe brake control (SBC), and so forth. Within the standard, IEC 61800-5-2 refers to the ISO 13849-1 standard and describes the requirements necessary for each subfunction to achieve a minimum PL. Moreover, aspects such as independence between systems, redundancy, and the processing time are discussed on both previously-mentioned standards and must be considered when implementing the system. Therefore, prior to starting the system implementation, understanding the key relationships between the safety requirements is important for each application, for each safety subfunctions that must be implemented, and for each level of required risk reduction (SIL or PL) for each subfunction. For this specific use-case (as summarized in Table 1 of the ISO 3691-4 standard), a minimum PLd safety level is required. Focusing on the motor drive subsystem, the safety subfunctions defined in the IEC 61800-5-2 standard are used to meet the PLd requirements.

Table 2-3 summarizes the main relationships between the three standards.

Table 2-3 Safety Requirements per the ISO 3691-4 Standard
Safety Function
per EN ISO 3691-4
Minimum Required PL per EN ISO 3691-4 Related Safety Subfunction per IEC 61800-5-2
Breaking System d/b SBC, SS1, STO
Speed control d/c SLS, SOS, STO
Automatic Battery Charging b NR(1)
Load Handling b NR(1)
Steering – SLS
Stability c NR(1)
Emergency Stop Function d STO
Personnel Detection Systems d/c SLS, SOS, SS1, STO SDI
Automatic, Manual, and Maintenance Modes d/c SLS, SOS, STO
Warning Systems a NR(1)
Access Into the Confined Zone d SOS, STO
NR: Implementation not related with the robot motor drive